Data Mining is an analytic process designed to explore data (usually large amounts of data – typically business or market related – also known as “big data”) in search of consistent patterns and/or systematic relationships between variables, and then to validate the findings by applying the detected patterns…
Two centuries ago, coal mining spurred the European continent’s Industrial Revolution. Today, data mining is fueling the data revolution brought about by exploding streams of data. Using data mining techniques to profile customer preferences and predict purchasing patterns has become common practice in the private sector. But can data mining also be used to fight corruption? And if so, how?
Last year, Transparency International Georgia launched an open-source procurement monitoring and analytics portal, which extracts data from the government’s central e-procurement website and repackages it into user-friendly formats. Users can now generate profiles of procurement transactions made by government agencies, profiles of companies bidding for public contracts, and search aggregate statistical data on government spending. If citizens suspect law violations in electronic tender processes they can submit an online report which a Dispute Resolution Board reviews within ten working days.
Data mining’s potential to spot inadequacies in processes involving elected authorities and public money can be taken even further.
The European Commission, in cooperation with Transparency International, developed ARACHNE data analytics software that cross-checks data from various public and private institutions and helps to identify projects susceptible to risks of fraud, conflict of interests or irregularities.
Researchers from the Corruption Research Center Budapest have examined massive data sets of public procurement procedures from European Union countries, searching for abnormal patterns such as exceptionally short bidding periods or unusual outcomes (e.g. no competition for the winning bid, or bids repeatedly won by the same company). Using inferential statistics – analysis that can be done to draw conclusions beyond what the data actually is capturing – they identified corrupt behavior based on deviations from ordinary patterns.
Data mining can also be used to detect tax fraud and improve taxpayer compliance. In the aftermath of the Luxleaks, when a whistleblower released reams of data about tax evasion schemes in Luxembourg, data mining techniques employed by New York City’s former finance commissioner David Frankel may provide some inspiration: by “identifying individuals who had businesses similar to others but who stood out as outliers on taxes paid” the auditing team improved the efficiency of its investigations into companies suspected of underpaying taxes.
Similarly, data mining could be employed to fight money laundering: an algorithm reviewing banking data and comparing it with information about financial criminal data points may for example contribute to revealing illicit financial flows, an issue that ranks high on Transparency International’s agenda.
The wealth of data that can nowadays be gathered through remote sensing, crowd-sourced citizen reports, news media, census data, cell phone activity, and social networking sites etc., combined with traditional indicators, makes for seemingly endless opportunities. Do you want to identify issues of conflict of interest and/or revolving doors? Do you want to know what people are thinking about corruption in a specific country context? Text mining techniques analysing social media noise during a given period of time may provide you with an answer.
There are many ways non-profits and civil society organisations can benefit from data mining on a pro-bono basis. These include hackathons and advocating for the replication of tools and platforms, which not only render data public but make it relatively easy to organize and process.
The European Citadel on the move website for instance allows users to upload data sets and to create personalized applications, even for people with little experience of data management. One of the most transparent and user-friendly initiatives at the local level is the website Checkbook NYC 2.0, which provides access to New York City government’s US$70 billion annual budget. It details the way money is spent, including specific information on contracts, payments, revenues, budget reports, and audits. It features an application programing interface that lets third-parties choose the data they want and then use it for their own purposes.
Data mining’s nimble and purpose-oriented character can do a lot to dispel the fog in which the public sector operates. But more efforts are needed to exploit its potential to the full and make it available to the widest audience.
Dominic Ienco’s career has spanned over 30 years of combining a strong immersion in music and entertainment with corporate advisory and business development services. He has assisted numerous emerging companies with the raising of capital and acting as a roving advisor he has been particularly successful in procuring international business partners for expanding corporations.
(Image credit: European Commission)